Earlier this year, during a mid-year staff meeting, one of our coaches told us about a morning with a student congress. For years, this congress had been filled by the students who always get picked, the ones with the good grades and the leadership titles. This year, however, the district asked teachers to nominate students who usually aren't picked, but were definitely leaders.
A few weeks into the school year, on that particular morning, one of the longtime student leaders – let’s call her Dee – pushed back on the work at hand, and a newer student leader – let’s call her Sonia – pushed right back. Sonia and other students told Dee that she was speaking from a place of privilege, that most students like Sonia had never been asked what they thought, or been given opportunities to lead. They asked Dee to step into their shoes. Dee got frustrated, felt embarrassed, and started to cry.
Then, the students who had just challenged her gathered around Dee. One of them asked, "How can I help you so that you don't feel like this?" Nobody sent her off to talk to an adult. When it settled, Dee turned to our coach and asked, "Is this what community schools is? Is this what you mean when you say ‘we all belong?’"
That morning’s conversations will never show up immediately in a change metric or in a real time test score. And yet, everyone in the room felt it.
This fall, EdSource asked who “deserves the credit” for a school district's strong academic record. The district in the story has a record to be proud of: an analysis found its students gained more ground between 2022 and 2025 than students in similar California districts.
The answer that stayed with me came from some of the teachers who have been there longest. They pointed to the district's learning communities, a long-running effort to help teachers work and learn together, one that started well before anyone thought to ask the question of who was going to “get credit.” What they described, underneath the headline on improved test scores, was a commitment from a group of adults who had come together to figure out how they might do better.
Everyone in this article is asking who gets the credit. I found myself asking a different question: how did these teachers build the conditions to support this growth, and how long did it take? Who was involved in that work? And why did none of the measures we rely on see this growth coming?
I believe adults and young people alike learn at the pace of trust. I've been sitting with what that pace actually is, though. It is slower than any grant cycle, any strategic plan, any accountability report. Belonging is built at that pace too.
That is the part that is so hard to measure. We tend to look for results in months. But belonging builds over years, and by the time it shows up in the scores, the scores end up as the headline. And more often than not, the journey gets lost.
In the districts CSLX works alongside, the credit belongs in large part to people whose names and actions rarely make it into any summative “outcomes” report. It's the teacher who greets each and every student personally, and with a smile. It's the school team willing to have difficult conversations and change how they work to better serve students. It's the Community School Coordinator (CSC) challenging people to share leadership, share space, share their stories. Not the headlines – the work.
Strong results are the return on years of investing in people belonging: teachers who belong to a shared practice, students who know they are wanted in the room, families who know the school is theirs, too. Everyone in the building feels it, every day, and it changes what they do. And yet it is rarely something we measure. How come?
Psychologists Greg Walton and Geoffrey Cohen gave first-year college students a single exercise, about an hour long, with one message: worrying about whether you fit in is common, and it can improve over time. Over the next three years, the Black students who experienced this exercise earned higher grades, and the achievement gap between them and their white classmates was cut in half. The exercise changed how they framed the hard days. They came to see them as something everyone goes through. By senior year, they didn't connect any of it to that one hour during their first year. Even the students it helped didn’t clearly “see” the cause.
When the researchers tested a version of the exercise with nearly 27,000 students at 22 colleges, it helped only where students' groups had real opportunities to belong. The setting made the difference. In West Contra Costa, the district changed the setting: it changed who was in the room, and the students did the rest. Across 82 studies of middle and high school students, belonging is linked to engagement and motivation, and to fewer absences and dropouts. One learning? As effective as a program or intervention might be, it’s only as strong as the sense of belonging participants feel.
And yet here we are, watching learning become depersonalized at a level and speed that scares me. So are we measuring the wrong thing?
Every California district is already expected to ask students about school safety and connectedness, often through the California Healthy Kids Survey (CHKS). On the state's school dashboard, though, the school climate rating shows only whether a district gave the survey and reported it to its board. What students said doesn't factor in. Sit with that for a moment. We ask every student whether they feel connected to school, and then rate the district on whether it asked, not on what students actually said.
This year we have been exploring with colleagues at WestEd how schools use that survey. Often the results are handled as a compliance task and the data never reaches the principals and teams who could act on it.
This is a common occurrence, and it’s not for lack of willingness. When we reflected with one of our district partners this year, we found that the most meaningful progress, including how a school feels when students, families, and educators walk in the door, is often the hardest to document. The data closest to measuring belonging is the data we are least set up to use.
The same holds in the other direction. When a school community decides that some students, or some teachers, should not be included as they are, the people in the building feel it right away. The data doesn't. It unravels more slowly. It shows up later, in who stopped raising a hand, which teachers quietly left, which families stopped coming through the door. Those students and adults are a small share of any district, so the average may never show it at all. A district can post a rising average while the people it stopped seeing quietly leave.
Belonging is not something we have to ration between students and their families. One of the hardest things that compassionate systems work asks us to do is to hold a paradox: to disagree with a decision completely, still constructively work alongside the people who made it, and wrestle with the forces that brought them to this decision point. Working together towards transformation is harder than picking a side.
Belonging in a school is never built by the school alone. In the districts we work alongside, we see it built by teachers and coordinators, and just as much by people whose names rarely make it into any report. In Fresno, the community school coordinators meet weekly to learn together and be honest about what isn't working yet. In West Contra Costa, family outreach staff have come to see welcoming families as the heart of their job. And it is built by parents who keep coming back, by student leaders like the ones in that congress, by neighbors, and by the community organizations whose staff make school a place of safety and care long after the bell.
One of the tools I learned from Peter Senge and Mette Böll, co-founders of the Compassionate Systems Framework, is called the ladder of inference. It traces how we climb from what we observe, to the data we select, to the conclusions we draw and the beliefs we adopt. Then it loops back: what we believe shapes which data we select next time. Schools climb that ladder too. When we only count scores, we come to believe scores are what matter, and scores become all we look for. Belonging never stops happening. We stop selecting it.
So we need to decide to look. Commit to it. We need to ask students, families and staff whether they belong, take the answers seriously, and keep asking. Then we choose to act, building the conditions that make the answer yes, slowly, alongside everyone it takes.
That is slow work, and it rarely gets the credit. But we know what it sounds like when it takes hold. It sounds like Dee, surrounded by classmates who had just challenged her, asking, "Is this what community schools is?"
Yes. It is.
Michelle's journey into educational justice began with a fundamental question: What would schools look like if they were truly designed for all students? This question has guided fifteen years of work centering the voices and experiences of young people who face the greatest barriers to educational opportunity—students in foster care, those experiencing homelessness, and youth navigating multiple systems that rarely coordinate to support their success.
Through her work building partnerships between schools, child welfare agencies, and community organizations, Michelle has focused on creating sustainable systems change. As Managing Director at the National Center for Youth Law, she led the design and implementation of the multi-state Compassionate Education Systems Initiative, collaborating alongside community partners and an talented staff team, the initiative created lasting change in the educational outcomes of young people across systems, and supporting the transition of demonstration projects into permanent public programs embedded within districts and public agencies, moving from philanthropic investment to long-term public ownership.
At the Stuart Foundation, Michelle developed and launched Education Equals, a $5 million annual initiative to improve education outcomes for students in foster care in California. She recruited and led youth leadership teams to advise grantmaking and evaluation strategy, and worked in close partnership with educators across Washington and California to understand opportunities and gaps at the intersection of child welfare and education.
In addition to serving as Managing Director II: Operations & Programs for the CA Community Schools Learning Exchange, Michelle previously served on CSLX's Advisory Board. Her work at the intersection of policy, practice, research, and youth development in education has included creating data linkage systems between child welfare and education agencies across multiple states and supporting policy staff in translating local demonstration lessons into statewide policy frameworks.
Michelle received her B.A. from Macalester College and certification in Compassionate Systems with the Center for Systems Awareness.
At its core, Michelle believes that love must be at the center of education—love for young people as they are, not as we think they should be. When schools become places where students feel genuinely seen, valued, and supported to thrive as whole human beings, transformation becomes possible. This isn't just about better coordination—it's about creating learning environments rooted in care, connection, and the unwavering belief that every child deserves to flourish.